WILD CORPUS · reddit

PQS 57 (C) - prompt from www.reddit.com

Source: www.reddit.com · Scraped 2026-05-04 · Scored 2026-05-04

Score

57 / 80

gemma4:latest · local · pqs-v2.0 · canonical

Clarity9 / 10

Specificity8 / 10

Context8 / 10

Constraints7 / 10

Output format7 / 10

Role definition9 / 10

Examples1 / 10

CoT structure8 / 10

The prompt

Most AI advice is generic and too agreeable so I built a framework called the Simulated Stakeholder Council (just to sound fancy haha). Instead of one answer i get the AI to simulate three distinct personas (The skeptic, the optimist and The technical lead) to argue against your idea. 

The Framework (you can copy paste this):

Role: You are an elite Multi Agent Decision Engine.

Task: Analyse the following proposal from three distinct perspectives:

The Skeptical CFO: Focus on ROI, hidden costs and "What if this fails?"

The Visionary Product Lead: Focus on long-term scale and user delight.

The Practical Engineer: Focus on technical debt, feasibility, and "How does this actually break?"

Process: &gt; - Each persona must provide 2 brutal critiques and 1 major opportunity.

After the critiques, provide a "Synthesis" that suggests a 10% improvement to the original plan.

Input Proposal: \[INSERT YOUR IDEA HERE\]

This prompt was scraped from a public source. The score reflects the input as written, not the quality of any output it produced. The AI input quality problem is the gap between what people type and what the model can act on.